Skip to main content
StorkScout

Feeding · current listings from independent shops

The best pacifiers

Pacifier preference is fiercely personal and decided entirely by the baby, so buy two or three shapes before stocking up. One-piece designs are the safest and simplest to keep clean.

Top 24 picks of 50 considered · 12 indie shops represented · $3–$99 (median $14) · checked live October 12, 2026 · how StorkScout works

Share

What to look for

  • One-piece construction with ventilation holes
  • Size ranges matched to age
  • Cherry, orthodontic, and flat shapes to trial

StorkScout may earn money from Shopify when you buy through product links. Sponsored results are labeled, and compensation never determines the Weekly Edit. How we make money

  1. Latch & Soothe™ Breastlike Pacifier
    Latch & Soothe™ Breastlike Pacifier
    $10★ 4.9 (137)
    Itzy Ritzy
  2. The Pacii™
    The Pacii™
    $14★ 4.5 (754)
    The Pacii
  3. Itzy Paci™ Pacifier 2-Pack - 0-6m
    Itzy Paci™ Pacifier 2-Pack - 0-6m
    $10★ 4.9 (163)
    Itzy Ritzy
  4. Ninni Pacifier Creme 1 Pack
    Ninni Pacifier Creme 1 Pack
    $14★ 4.7 (342)
    Ninni Co.
  5. Cutie PAT Round (0-6m) Pacifier + Teether
    Cutie PAT Round (0-6m) Pacifier + Teether
    $99★ 5.0 (196)
    Ryan And Rose
  6. Cutie PAT Flat (0m+) Pacifier + Teether
    Cutie PAT Flat (0m+) Pacifier + Teether
    $3★ 5.0 (214)
    Ryan And Rose
  7. Itzy Soother™ Natural Rubber Pacifier - 0-6m
    Itzy Soother™ Natural Rubber Pacifier - 0-6m
    $10★ 4.9 (180)
    Itzy Ritzy
  8. Cutie PAT Slant (0-6m) Pacifier + Teether
    Cutie PAT Slant (0-6m) Pacifier + Teether
    $3★ 5.0 (130)
    Ryan And Rose
  9. 2 Pack Colour Pacifiers
    2 Pack Colour Pacifiers
    $17★ 5.0 (2)
    Colored Organics
  10. Pacifier Starter Kit
    Pacifier Starter Kit
    $15★ 4.9 (184)
    Ryan And Rose
  11. The Emulait Pacifier 2-Pack
    The Emulait Pacifier 2-Pack
    $14★ 4.2 (203)
    Emulait
  12. Cutie PAT Smile (0m+) Pacifier + Teether
    Cutie PAT Smile (0m+) Pacifier + Teether
    $3★ 4.9 (200)
    Ryan And Rose
  13. Suavinex Color Essence Silicone Pacifier 2 Pack
    Suavinex Color Essence Silicone Pacifier 2 Pack
    $16★ 5.0 (81)
    Suavinex USA
  14. Supreme Blush - Flowpack Packaging
    Supreme Blush - Flowpack Packaging
    $4
    BIBS B2B US
  15. Cutie PAT Bulb (0-6m) Pacifier + Teether
    Cutie PAT Bulb (0-6m) Pacifier + Teether
    $99★ 5.0 (162)
    Ryan And Rose
  16. Itzy Soother™ Natural Rubber Pacifier - 6-18m
    Itzy Soother™ Natural Rubber Pacifier - 6-18m
    $10★ 5.0 (42)
    Itzy Ritzy
  17. Bitzy Pal™ Natural Rubber Pacifier & Lovey
    Bitzy Pal™ Natural Rubber Pacifier & Lovey
    $14★ 5.0 (89)
    Itzy Ritzy
  18. Supreme 2 PACK Ivory/Blush
    Supreme 2 PACK Ivory/Blush
    $8
    BIBS B2B US
  19. mōmi babypace® breast-like pacifier in multiple vibrant colors
    mōmi babypace® breast-like pacifier in multiple vibrant colors
    $14★ 5.0 (1)
    mōmi
  20. Active Flexy Pacifier (4m+)
    Active Flexy Pacifier (4m+)
    $15★ 4.9 (222)
    Nanobébé
  21. Pacifier 2 Pack
    Pacifier 2 Pack
    $15★ 4.3 (148)
    Minbie US
  22. Colour Blush
    Colour Blush
    $4
    BIBS B2B US
  23. Bibs Pacifier Original Colour 2 Pack : Size 1 (0-6M)
    Bibs Pacifier Original Colour 2 Pack : Size 1 (0-6M)
    $16
    Banana Split Children's Boutique
  24. SmilePRO Pacifier
    SmilePRO Pacifier
    $15★ 5.0 (4)
    Ryan And Rose

How this guide is built

This guide requests pacifiers listings live from Shopify Catalog and preserves the order Catalog returns. StorkScout does not reorder results based on commission. If promoted placements appear, they are clearly labeled. Products on this week's StorkScout Edit are badged. Read the full methodology.

More feeding guides