Skip to main content
StorkScout

Apparel · current listings from independent shops

The best newborn mittens

Scratch mittens protect faces from surprisingly sharp newborn nails. The failure mode is falling off, so cuffs and built-in designs win over cute standalone pairs.

Top 24 picks of 50 considered · 18 indie shops represented · $4–$45 (median $16) · checked live October 12, 2026 · how StorkScout works

Share

What to look for

  • Deep, gently elastic cuffs
  • Sleepers with fold-over cuffs as an alternative
  • Soft interiors with no loose threads

StorkScout may earn money from Shopify when you buy through product links. Sponsored results are labeled, and compensation never determines the Weekly Edit. How we make money

  1. Scratch Mitten in Oat
    Scratch Mitten in Oat
    $7★ 5.0 (85)
    Kyte Baby
  2. Snow Mitts - Baby
    Snow Mitts - Baby
    $22★ 4.7 (17)
    Stonz
  3. Baby knit mittens
    Baby knit mittens
    $17★ 5.0 (14)
    Primary.com
  4. 4-Pack Baby Girls Flower Pot No Scratch Mittens
    4-Pack Baby Girls Flower Pot No Scratch Mittens
    $6★ 5.0 (16)
    Gerber Childrenswear
  5. Disana - Organic Merino Wool Infant Mittens - Knit
    Disana - Organic Merino Wool Infant Mittens - Knit
    $27★ 5.0 (1)
    Nature's Wild Child
  6. Organic Cotton Baby Mittens 3 Pack - Ranunculus
    Organic Cotton Baby Mittens 3 Pack - Ranunculus
    $13★ 3.9 (8)
    Burt's Bees Baby
  7. Grab Bag: Mitten
    Grab Bag: Mitten
    $32★ 5.0 (18)
    Lou Lou & Company
  8. 8-Pack Baby Neutral White No Scratch Mittens
    8-Pack Baby Neutral White No Scratch Mittens
    $16★ 4.6 (18)
    Gerber Childrenswear
  9. Baby knit mittens in multi-stripe
    Baby knit mittens in multi-stripe
    $20
    Primary.com
  10. STAY ON 2-PACK MITTS | MANY MOONS + PEBBLE — Bamboo Organic Cotton Blend, 0–6M
    STAY ON 2-PACK MITTS | MANY MOONS + PEBBLE — Bamboo Organic Cotton Blend, 0–6M
    $20★ 5.0 (4)
    goumikids
  11. Cozie Fleece Baby Mitten - Cream
    Cozie Fleece Baby Mitten - Cream
    $15★ 4.9 (15)
    Zutano
  12. Michigan Go Blue! FanMitts™
    Michigan Go Blue! FanMitts™
    $25★ 5.0 (15)
    Day1Fans.com
  13. Baby Mittens - Blue Stripe
    Baby Mittens - Blue Stripe
    $8
    MORI US
  14. MIKI HOUSE Logo Mittens
    MIKI HOUSE Logo Mittens
    $45
    MIKI HOUSE USA
  15. Scratch Mitten in Cloud
    Scratch Mitten in Cloud
    $4
    Kyte Baby Wholesale
  16. STAY ON BABY MITTENS | MIDNIGHT BY GOUMIKIDS
    STAY ON BABY MITTENS | MIDNIGHT BY GOUMIKIDS
    $16★ 5.0 (10)
    goumikids
  17. 8-Piece Baby Girls Golden Floral No Scratch Mittens & Caps Set
    8-Piece Baby Girls Golden Floral No Scratch Mittens & Caps Set
    $16★ 4.6 (10)
    Gerber Childrenswear
  18. White Kissy Basics Mittens
    White Kissy Basics Mittens
    $11★ 4.7 (11)
    Kissy Kissy
  19. Infant Knit Mittens With String Off-White
    Infant Knit Mittens With String Off-White
    $26
    Maisonette
  20. 8-Piece Baby Neutral Southwest No Scratch Mittens & Caps Set
    8-Piece Baby Neutral Southwest No Scratch Mittens & Caps Set
    $16★ 5.0 (1)
    Gerber Childrenswear
  21. Simple Stripe Mitts
    Simple Stripe Mitts
    $12
    Maisonette
  22. Texas A&M Gig 'Em Maroon Newborn Baby Mittens
    Texas A&M Gig 'Em Maroon Newborn Baby Mittens
    $25★ 5.0 (3)
    Aggieland Outfitters
  23. No Scratch Mittens
    No Scratch Mittens
    $10
    Falcon Creek Boutique
  24. Striped No Scratch Mittens (Babies)
    Striped No Scratch Mittens (Babies)
    $6
    Witching Hour Baby

How this guide is built

This guide requests newborn mittens listings live from Shopify Catalog and preserves the order Catalog returns. StorkScout does not reorder results based on commission. If promoted placements appear, they are clearly labeled. Products on this week's StorkScout Edit are badged. Read the full methodology.

More apparel guides